The Scoop on D3 Women’s Hoops by Riley Zayas

February 19, 2024

It’s been a few days since I posted a write-up here, but we’re in the postseason now (for almost everyone with the exception of the UAA) and I’m excited for what is to come. You can expect much more consistent coverage here as we follow along through conference tournaments and into this weekend as the NCAA Tournament discussions ramp up. This is such a fun time of the year to be following D3 women’s hoops!

I wanted to quickly recap some of the most impactful games of the weekend (all of them coming from Saturday’s slate) from a regional ranking/Pool C perspective. As I will note below, these were games that could shift regional rankings as well as the Pool C conversation and there will certainly be plenty more of these in the week ahead.

Before I get to that though, I wanted to quickly mention a few things…

• The Conference Tournament Tracker is up on D3hoops.com…find that here and keep up with all of the tournament games across the country!
• All data referenced here is from Scott Peterson’s D3 WBB website, d3data.weebly.com. Check it out if you get a chance. Lots of insightful data there, especially with Pool C outlook and projected final regional rankings.
• I will probably not be putting out a Top 25 ballot breakdown this week as I want to focus more on regional rankings and conference tournaments. At this point in the year, those are the things that will be much more impactful to the national audience than my Top 25, but a screenshot of my ballot is below.

Most impactful games of the weekend
Scranton def. Elizabethtown, 67-58: The odds were stacked against Elizabethtown, playing on the road, but the Blue Jays certainly had a chance to knock off the Lady Royals, already holding one win over Scranton this season. But the Lady Royals defended their home court well, and in the process, eliminated Elizabethtown from Pool C contention. It is possible Elizabethtown remains regionally-ranked, which will help Scranton and Catholic, but the Blue Jays will likely fall to the No. 7 spot in Region 5.

Hardin-Simmons def. Mary Hardin-Baylor, 88-85: UMHB’s resume was not impacted all that much by the overtime loss at home to close the regular season, but HSU put itself in even more of a firm Pool C position, in the event the Cowgirls do not win the league tournament. UMHB’s Pool C resume remains solid as well, and it is likely we see The Cru still sitting at No. 1 in Region 10 tomorrow. For HSU, this was big, as the Cowgirls have been a bubble-in team for the last several weeks. Now, it’s safe to stay HSU is a lock to get into the tournament, with a projected final 865/523 resume.

Nazareth def. St. John Fisher, 73-65: In Region 3, this was a big win for Nazareth, who went down the road and took down its bitter rival. Due to an SOS tiebreaker, SJF got the top seed in the E8 Tournament, but there’s a chance Nazareth might jump ahead of SJF in Region 3. Maybe. SJF was No. 5 last week in R3, while Nazareth was No. 6. SJF is now 21-4, while the Golden Flyers are 22-3. In terms of projected resumes, Nazareth has an edge via both win percentage (+15 points) and SOS (+2 points). But current resumes are what is used. SJF has a slight edge on SOS, but it is very narrow. The two teams split their season series, and interestingly, both lost to Houghton two weeks ago. There are plenty of common opponents between the two, including Rochester, who Nazareth lost to, while SJF beat. I think SJF still probably stays ahead, but Nazareth’s head-to-head win makes this something to keep an eye on.

Vassar def. Ithaca, 66-59: Another big Region 3 result here. Vassar was No. 2, and Ithaca was No. 4 this past week in the regional rankings. Vassar lost to William Smith last week before bouncing back with this Ithaca win. By Vassar winning this one, I think it keeps them ahead in Region 3, which will be important considering three Liberty League teams are currently in the Top 4 in this region. Even with the loss, Ithaca’s Pool C resume is really solid. For Vassar to execute on the road like they did, coming off a bad loss, is impressive to me.

UW-Stout def. UW-Platteville, 66-52: I tell you what, Stout continues fighting elimination, and did so against a really good UW-Platteville team on Saturday. Stout found itself in a position six games into conference play in which the Blue Devils really couldn’t afford another loss without falling out of Pool C contention, and since that point, they’ve only lost once, to Oshkosh. Everything else has been a win, and Stout is currently sitting No. 6 in Region 9. With the depth in the region, they are the definition of a bubble team, with a slim Pool C possibility but a need to continue winning. Every time they step onto the court, they are fighting elimination from Pool C contention. As a reminder, tonight’s result against UW-River Falls has zero bearing on where Stout ends up in tomorrow’s regional rankings. Only games through Sunday are considered.

Marietta def. Baldwin Wallace, 71-56: The final team ranked in Region 7, Marietta kept itself in the Pool C conversation with this win over the OAC’s top team and did so on the road, which is so impressive. Margin of victory isn’t included in the NCAA regional ranking or Pool C conversation, but for my own assessment, I thought the 15-point win really added significance to Marietta’s victory. The Pioneers won that game on both ends of the floor, but are still going to be on the outside of the Pool C discussion. I think the Pool C chances are slight for Marietta, but still, this win at least keeps the Pioneers in the conversation. If you’re a Marietta fan, you need to be rooting for as few bid thieves as possible. It’s going to take a strong performance at the OAC Tournament and reaching the championship game. Of course, if Marietta wins the championship game, we don’t have to talk about the Pool C chances.

CalTech def. Whittier, 59-47 : CalTech played spoiler in the SCIAC on Saturday, and eliminated Whittier from the SCIAC playoffs, and as a result, NCAA Tournament contention. Whittier notably fell by just four points at NYU earlier this season, and seemed like a team that could make noise in the NCAA Tournament if they got in. As it turned out, Whittier’s season is already over. Only the top four teams in the SCIAC make the postseason, and the Poets ended up tied for fifth after the loss (at home!) to CalTech. Just a disappointing finish to what was a very promising season early, but credit to CalTech for pulling off that big win.

Piedmont def. Berea, 57-50: This result won’t affect the NCAA Tournament as Berea should be the Pool B selection by a significant margin. But it could affect the Region 6 regional rankings. Berea was No. 7 in R6 last week, and I have to think there’s a chance Berea falls out with this loss and Millsaps gets in. It’ll be close, and Berea’s 22-3 record is strong, but the 469 SOS is not good, especially with a committee that values SOS highly. We saw it with undefeated Webster being unranked. So I’m not sure 22-3 is automatically going to keep Berea in. But then again, Millsaps 472 SOS is only three points higher, and doesn’t seem like enough to overcome 73 points of win percentage. So we’ll see.

Game of the Day: UW-River Falls at UW-Stout (WIAC Tournament)

As I already mentioned, this is a must-win for Stout in terms of staying alive in Pool C. And for UWRF, it is also a must-win. It’s tournament time. Neither team really has a Pool C berth to fall back on, so it heightens the intensity of this matchup that much more. What makes it more interesting is that both matchups this season have been especially close and competitive. They just played last Wednesday with Stout at home, and the Blue Devils emerged with a 71-66 win. I fully expect a similar-type game tonight, and both teams can shoot the ball well. UWRF is one of the top 3-point shooting teams in the league, so Stout’s perimeter defense needs to be on point through all four quarters, and Macy Nilsen always tends to be a tough matchup for the Stout defense. She is one of the more dynamic scorers in the WIAC, and scored 29 points in last week’s meeting with the Blue Devils. Stout has a high scorer of its own in Raegan Sorensen, who had 35 points against UW-Eau Claire two weeks ago, and both Nilsen and Sorensen rank in the top three in points per game in the WIAC. 7 p.m. CT tip-off from Menomonie tonight. Watch here: https://wiacnetwork.com/stout/

Have a great rest of your day! I’ll check back in tomorrow morning and take a look back on how tonight’s conference tournament action unfolded.