post

ATN Podcast 426: The infamous dials, and a bracket full of new faces

The bracket is set. Forty teams are in, eight first-round games are on deck, and 24 teams have a first-round bye. Whether they are the right ones, well, that’s another story. And for the first time, the NESCAC is part of the picture, with Amherst, Trinity (Conn.) and Wesleyan all in the field.

Patrick and Greg break down Selection Sunday. That includes a late-afternoon NPI shuffle that moved Heidelberg from bubble-out to solidly in, some dramatic winner-take-all games (and some less dramatic ones) and teams needing wins to secure home games that didn’t always get what they needed.

This edition of the D3football.com Podcast is sponsored by GameStrat, the most reliable & fastest in-game video replay system on the market. Now is the time to get GameStrat for your playoff games! Find out more at GameStrat.com.

Plus, who was left out? Bethel finished No. 14 in the D3football.com Top 25, but only 11 at-large bids were available. That makes Bethel the highest-ranked team left out since 2021, and the first time under NPI and the expanded bracket that more than one ranked team missed the cut.

We go through our likes and dislikes about the bracket, including more likes than dislikes, the best first-round games, second-round matchups to watch, and a first-round team that could make some noise.

Plus, we talk with acting committee chair, Keith Buckley, about the bracket. Here’s the topics:

  • How the committee approached bracketing with NESCAC teams in the mix.
  • Whether the NPI “dials” can still be changed, and why the committee can only recommend changes to the champs committee.
  • Placing hard-to-place teams, travel and budget limits, and the seed-line balance of the 16/8/8 structure.
  • Patrick’s seed-total math on the four quadrants, why Calvin and Whitewater weren’t paired, and the 3-4 and 5-6 pairings in the top left.
  • A question about the NESCAC’s strength of schedule and a closed-conference schedule. The committee will take it up at its February meeting.

Plus we hand out game balls, go region by region, deliver our stats of the week and answer your mailbag questions. So many questions!

  • How much do non-conference games matter if the NESCAC gets three teams in without playing any?
  • Could the NESCAC have been the best conference in D-III all along, and how many playoff wins should we expect?
  • Why did Mount Union decline its bowl game?
  • Should the bracket expand to 48 teams?
  • Should Division III adopt the Division II playoff model?

Patrick and Greg cover it all in Around the Nation Podcast No. 426. Hit play, or subscribe to get this podcast on your mobile device.

You can subscribe to the Around the Nation Podcast in Apple Podcasts, and many other places. You can also get this and any of our future Around the Nation podcasts automatically by subscribing to this RSS feed: http://www.d3blogs.com/d3football/?feed=podcast

Here’s how to find us on some of the major podcasting apps:

Photos: W&J athletics photo by Stephen Rydzak; Claremont-Mudd-Scripps athletics photo by Giselle Lai