The story goes, one day on a long ride to a playoff game at Thiel (which tells you how long ago this happened), Pat and Keith decided to pass the time by guessing not just the winner of each first-round playoff game, but the score. And there was born the expectations game: Do we expect a close game? A high-scoring game? A blowout? Does everyone agree on who will win? Those are the factors worth looking at.
Keith McMillan, Ryan Tipps, Pat Coleman, Adam Turer, Frank Rossi and Greg Thomas each take their guesses at scores for each first-round game. We also looped in the Hansen Ratings, updated with playoff experience as a factor, for anther objective take. The algorithm takes into account both home-field advantage and playoff experience, so a game such as Hardin-Simmons and Linfield, between teams with identical team ratings, ends up with Linfield given a 65 percent chance to win.
— Pat Coleman (Linfield athletics photo)
UW-Oshkosh bracket | |
Keith’s take: UW-Oshkosh 56, Lakeland 21 Ryan’s take: UW-Oshkosh 49, Lakeland 13 Pat’s take: UW-Oshkosh 47, Lakeland 13 |
Adam’s take: UW-Oshkosh 52, Lakeland 7 Frank’s take: UW-Oshkosh 34, Lakeland 6 Greg’s take: UW-Oshkosh 52, Lakeland 14 |
Hansen odds to advance: UW-Oshkosh, 99%. Consensus: UW-Oshkosh in a walk, though Lakeland could score a few points. |
|
Keith’s take: North Central 22, St. John’s 21 Ryan’s take: North Central 27, St. John’s 23 Pat’s take: North Central 31, St. John’s 28 |
Adam’s take: North Central 10, St. John’s 7 Frank’s take: St. John’s 21, North Central 20 Greg’s take: North Central 24, St. John’s 23 |
Hansen odds to advance: St. John’s, 58%. Consensus: North Central, in a close game, and a split decision. |
|
Keith’s take: Wartburg 38, Franklin 24 Ryan’s take: Wartburg 30, Franklin 27 Pat’s take: Wartburg 45, Franklin 31 |
Adam’s take: Wartburg 35, Franklin 27 Frank’s take: Wartburg 44, Franklin 31 Greg’s take: Wartburg 38, Franklin 28 |
Hansen odds to advance: Wartburg, 79%. Consensus: Wartburg the consensus winner, though everyone respect’s Franklin’s ability to score. |
|
Keith’s take: Trine 19, Monmouth 16 Ryan’s take: Monmouth 31, Trine 20 Pat’s take: Monmouth 31, Trine 28 |
Adam’s take: Trine 17, Monmouth 13 Frank’s take: Trine 48, Monmouth 40 Greg’s take: Trine 38, Monmouth 28 |
Hansen odds to advance: Trine, 58%. Consensus: Wide variety of opinions. Two Trine slugfest wins, two Trine defensive battle wins, two Monmouth wins. |
Mount Union bracket | |
Keith’s take: Mount Union 56, Wash. & Lee 14 Ryan’s take: Mount Union 51, Wash. & Lee 7 Pat’s take: Mount Union 48, Wash. & Lee 10 |
Adam’s take: Mount Union 49, Wash. & Lee 20 Frank’s take: Mount Union 60, Wash. & Lee 10 Greg’s take: Mount Union 56, Wash. & Lee 7 |
Hansen odds to advance: Mount Union, 99%. Consensus: Mount Union, in a win that a No. 1 seed would be satisfied with. |
|
Keith’s take: Illinois Wesleyan 35, Case 13 Ryan’s take: Illinois Wesleyan 31, Case 21 Pat’s take: Illinois Wesleyan 35, Case 17 |
Adam’s take: Illinois Wesleyan 21, Case 16 Frank’s take: Case 31, Illinois Wesleyan 30 Greg’s take: Illinois Wesleyan 28, Case 10 |
Hansen odds to advance: Illinois Wesleyan, 61%. Consensus: IWU generally winning handily, with one outlier. |
|
Keith’s take: W&J 42, Johns Hopkins 30 Ryan’s take: Johns Hopkins 35, W&J 34 Pat’s take: Johns Hopkins 28, W&J 24 |
Adam’s take: Johns Hopkins 38, W&J 34 Frank’s take: Johns Hopkins 35, W&J 28 Greg’s take: Johns Hopkins 27, W&J 24 |
Hansen odds to advance: Johns Hopkins, 68%. Consensus: Wow. Consensus is the road team. But consensus is also an exciting game. |
|
Keith’s take: Wittenberg 17, Frostburg State 14 Ryan’s take: Frostburg State 27, Wittenberg 24 Pat’s take: Wittenberg 17, Frostburg State 15 |
Adam’s take: Wittenberg 30, Frostburg State 24 Frank’s take: Frostburg State 27, Wittenberg 24 Greg’s take: Wittenberg 14, Frostburg State 10 |
Hansen odds to advance: Wittenberg, 59%. Consensus: Generally low-scoring, all around, and generally with Wittenberg by a field goal or less. |
Mary Hardin-Baylor bracket | |
Keith’s take: UMHB 40, Chapman 20 Ryan’s take: UMHB 48, Chapman 10 Pat’s take: UMHB 42, Chapman 17 |
Adam’s take: UMHB 58, Chapman 10 Frank’s take: UMHB 37, Chapman 10 Greg’s take: UMHB 48, Chapman 7 |
Hansen odds to advance: Mary Hardin-Baylor, 98%. Consensus: The defending champs, by a lot. |
|
Keith’s take: Hardin-Simmons 14, Linfield 13 Ryan’s take: Hardin-Simmons 27, Linfield 14 Pat’s take: Hardin-Simmons 24, Linfield 19 |
Adam’s take: Hardin-Simmons 21, Linfield 17 Frank’s take: Linfield 14, Hardin-Simmons 10 Greg’s take: Hardin-Simmons 24, Linfield 10 |
Hansen odds to advance: Linfield, 65%. Consensus: HSU favored on the road, with Linfield kicking an undetermined number of field goa.s. |
|
Keith’s take: St. Thomas 63, Eureka 0 Ryan’s take: St. Thomas 58, Eureka 7 Pat’s take: St. Thomas 56, Eureka 6 |
Adam’s take: St. Thomas 63, Eureka 13 Frank’s take: St. Thomas 51, Eureka 13 Greg’s take: St. Thomas 63, Eureka 0 |
Hansen odds to advance: St. Thomas, > 99%. Consensus: Tommies. Not in a mood to break scoring records. |
|
Keith’s take: Berry 28, Huntingdon 24 Ryan’s take: Berry 35, Huntingdon 28 Pat’s take: Berry 24, Huntingdon 21 |
Adam’s take: Berry 27, Huntingdon 24 Frank’s take: Huntingdon 34, Berry 28 Greg’s take: Berry 28, Huntingdon 17 |
Hansen odds to advance: Huntingdon, 57%. Consensus: Berry. Mostly. Except for the one usual outlier. |
Delaware Valley bracket | |
Keith’s take: Delaware Valley 38, Western NE 20 Ryan’s take: Delaware Valley 49, Western NE 17 Pat’s take: Delaware Valley 31, Western NE 10 |
Adam’s take: Delaware Valley 35, Western NE 14 Frank’s take: Delaware Valley 30, Western NE 21 Greg’s take: Delaware Valley 33, Western NE 13 |
Hansen odds to advance: Delaware Valley, 95% Consensus: Delaware Valley, by a range of points but all by multiple scores. |
|
Keith’s take: Springfield 42, Husson 28 Ryan’s take: Springfield 38, Husson 35 Pat’s take: Springfield 45, Husson 31 |
Adam’s take: Springfield 38, Husson 24 Frank’s take: Springfield 42, Husson 20 Greg’s take: Springfield 42, Husson 21 |
Hansen odds to advance: Springfield, 83% Consensus: Springfield, generally comfortable, generally in a high-scoring game. |
|
Keith’s take: Brockport 39, Plymouth State 13 Ryan’s take: Brockport 35, Plymouth State 10 Pat’s take: Brockport 24, Plymouth State 7 |
Adam’s take: Brockport 28, Plymouth State 20 Frank’s take: Brockport 27, Plymouth State 7 Greg’s take: Brockport 24, Plymouth State 7 |
Hansen odds to advance: Brockport, 99% Consensus: Brockport, generally comfortably, generally in a low-scoring game. |
|
Keith’s take: Wesley 27, RPI 10 Ryan’s take: Wesley 38, RPI 6 Pat’s take: Wesley 38, RPI 14 |
Adam’s take: Wesley 41, RPI 12 Frank’s take: Wesley 37, RPI 17 Greg’s take: Wesley 38, RPI 10 |
Hansen odds to advance: Wesley, 91% Consensus: Wesley makes it final: No upsets expected in this bracket. |
Here’s more data from Hansen Ratings. Select any two playoff teams to see how they would compare in a real or hypothetical matchup
We invite you to add your predictions in the comments below, or tweet at @d3football. Download the Around the Nation podcast on Mondays, where Pat and Keith review the picks and the highlights from the first round.