Stagg Bowl XXXIV preview

Alright, since so many people are interested in talking about the Stagg Bowl matchup like it’s a given Mount Union and UW-Whitewater will meet again, let’s look at the Stagg Bowl for a second.

Without being a homer, what matchup would you most like to see in the Stagg Bowl? Use your creativity here.

Here’s some for starters:

Rowan vs. Washington and Jefferson, Union vs. Lycoming. These are the four teams who have lost more than one Stagg Bowl and never won any. Presumably if these teams played, someone would win.

Augustana vs. Mount Union, especially if it could be Augustana ’86 against Mount Union ’02, the cappers of the dynasties.

Illinois College vs. Mississippi College. If you squint it looks like a bowl game. Maybe ESPN would hiccup and put it in prime time.

It’s hardly more ridiculous to discuss these than it is to discuss a Stagg Bowl taking place 1,100 games from now.

Did I mention about not being a homer?

Instant reactions to Week 1 results

Not sure if I want to step on Pat and Gordon’s Sunday tradition of “immediate thoughts on Week 1” so the door is open for a separate blog tomorrow if this doesn’t cover the bases.

I was supposed to go to Salisbury at Washington & Jefferson today, before a confluence of events finally got me to admit at 4 a.m. last night that there was a 50% chance I wouldn’t/shouldn’t go.

I still wanted to see the game, a both teams. Perhaps I should have. Because although my first idea for ATN this week died right there on the field (how having 5 O-Lineman back precipitates early success), a new one seems to have been born.

The mid-Atlantic shakeup. It’s only 4:38, and already No. 15 W&J has gone down by double digits and two 2005 conference champions from the mid-Atlantic have taken losses (Ferrum, 49-35 at Guilford and Johns Hopkins, 20-10 at home vs. Rochester).

Salisbury, meanwhile, is a mid-Atlantic 2004 playoff team perhaps on track towards getting back, unlike Shenandoah, who did not impress in a 17-6 loss to Catholic on Thursday.

As for selfish pats on the back, I believe I used the word “smoked” in conjunction with Mount Union-Averett in ATN this week (64-7 final), but I, uh, also, may have, uh, indicated that possibly Waynesburg could hang with No. 8 Wesley. (41-14 final).

You win some, you lose some???

Open for other thoughts …

Looking forward to Week 1

So we’re finally ready to kick off the Division III season!

What’s that? There were games already tonight? Three of them? Really?

Hm.

Well, here are my two-cents (plink, plink) on this week’s action any way.

Wish you were here: If I could be at any Division III game this week, it would be UW-Stevens Point versus No. 11 Hardin-Simmons.

Lots of interesting story lines here. It’s a measure of the West (Stevens Point) and South (HSU) Regions strength, as Keith McMillan points out. It’s the return of Cowboys QB Jordan Neal who missed most of last season for Hardin-Simmons.

Plus it’s a chance for Stevens Point to show 2006 will be better than 2005. On the third play from scrimmage last year HSU running back Quinton Jones ripped through the Pointers’ defense for a 61-yard touchdown. The Cowboys rolled to a 38-12 win and Stevens Point was headed toward a 1-4 start. This Saturday is a second chance for the Pointers to make a first impression.

Don’t sleep on this one: Wilmington finished ninth in the OAC last season. Mt. St. Joseph won the HCAC and its automatic bid to the playoffs. But Wilmington played the Lions tough last year, holding them to -21 yards rushing in a 21-17 loss. The Quakers could score a win in this Cincinnati area skirmish.

Looking ahead: No. 25 Thiel plays Geneva College. The Golden Tornados are slated to join Division III and the President’s Athletic Conference (PAC) in 2007. And, with this mascot, I’m already looking forward to it.

Open House: Minnesota-Morris opens Big Cat Stadium against Lawrence. Looking at the photos, the place looks pretty nice. Plus the Cougars already have a 14 point lead according to that one picture!

As we detailed this summer, lots of other schools will also get to show off their improvements over the next couple weeks.

Just throwing it out there: With Saturday’s game against UW-Eau Claire, St. John’s Head Coach John Gagliardi enter his 58th season and set a new record for most seasons as a college football head coach. He’s currently tied with Amos Alonzo Stagg, namesake for Division III’s championship game.

Speaking of which, would there be any interest in renaming the title game once Gagliardi retires? How about the Gagliardi-Stagg Bowl? Someone else may’ve suggested this before and I thought it merits consideration.

Most likely Top 25 team to lose: Could be No. 25 Thiel since Geneva hosts and is a solid program. Huntingdon might be a trendy pick, but winning at No. 24 Ithaca is a tall task. Yes, Huntingdon was one quarter away from beating SCAC-power Trinity (Texas) last season. They also lost to 3-7 Maryville (Tenn.).

Super ridiculous pick of the week: I do this every week and have never been right. But optimism abounds in Week 1. In fact, I’m feeling so good that I’m picking not just an upset, but predicting the score.

So let’s go with St. Thomas in a last minute victory over No. 18 Central. The Tommies narrowly missed beating Coe who beat Central last year. And everyone knows comparative scores are always accurate!

St. Thomas 21 No. 18 Central 17

And finally…

Brought to you by Mapquest: NAIA’s Valley City State, hosting St. Olaf.